What are your clients getting away with?

Often when I reflect on how my clients approach their responsibilities and obligations, there seem to be two general approaches.  Some focus on seeing “what can I get away with?”, while others go for “what can I do?”.  They have very different implications for how they are living and how they operate in relationship. It’s something we need to be alert to and help our clients recognise.

1.What can I get away with?  

The benign version is the apparently self-serving “how little can I get away with?”.  I approach my commitments trying to work out how little I can do to avoid failure, punishment or approbation…  This involves making no investment in what I am responsible for. Often there is an element of deliberately not trying, for fear of failing.  Justification for this approach is often achieved by seeing what I need to do as a demand placed on me by someone else, rather than a responsibility that belongs to me because of choices I have made.  

The more sinister version is “what kind of harm and mayhem can I get away with, how much can I make others pay for my pain (typically while still plausibly denying I am doing any such thing)?”  This is the dark side that we practice, most commonly, on our families and loved ones, though it is a complete lifestyle for some.  Often I struggle to consciously see this in myself and others because my family was so expert at denying the reality of what they were doing that I have a large blind spot about this kind of behaviour.  That is, when I do it and/or when others do it to me, I don’t recognise it as bad; it just seems normal, unremarkable.  The tragedy is that every time I work someone over, I increase my disconnection and pain, making it more likely I will be inclined to make others suffer in the future.

There is a different question, that reflects a very different attitude:

2. What can I do?  

This also comes in two forms.  At the simplest level it means proactively engaging with my responsibilities, working out what needs to be done to discharge them well, and doing that.  Not because someone told me to, or because I will look bad if I don’t, but because I know I am defined by my choices and my behaviour (NOT by my intentions or feelings) and I want to live a life of integrity and self-respect.

However the joy of embracing the notion of “what can I do?” is not simply the satisfaction of living up to my responsibilities.  Approached whole-heartedly it means investing fully in the things I have chosen for my life and discovering what I am capable of.  Not just working hard, but taking risks and learning new things about myself and the world.  It is the continuous work of becoming more fully who I am and who I want to be.

As therapists, we want to help our clients understand the dangers of the first approach and see if they can find their way to the joy of fulfilment. It’s up to us to be clear with them about which way works.